| Date | Champion | Location |
| 08/12/92 | Johnny Hotbody | Philadelphia, PA |
| 09/30/92 | Glen Osbourne | Philadelphia, PA |
| 03/12/93 | Jimmy Snuka | Radnor, PA |
| 10/01/93 | Terry Funk | Philadelphia, PA |
| 11/13/93 | Sabu | Philadelphia, PA |
| 03/06/94 | Tazmaniac | Philadelphia, PA |
| 03/06/94 | J.T. Smith | Philadelphia, PA |
| 04/16/94 | Pitbull #1 | Philadelphia, PA |
| 05/13/94 | Mickey Whipwreck | Philadelphia, PA |
| 08/13/94 | Jason | Philadelphia, PA |
| 11/04/94 | 2 Cold Scorpio | Hamburg, PA |
| 11/04/94 | Dean Malenko | Hamburg, PA |
| 03/18/95 | 2 Cold Scorpio (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 04/08/95 | Eddie Guerrero | Philadelphia, PA |
| 07/21/95 | Dean Malenko (2) | Tampa, FL |
| 07/28/95 | Eddie Guerrero (2) | Middletown, NY |
| 08/25/95 | 2 Cold Scorpio (3) | Jim Thorpe, PA |
| 12/29/95 | Mickey Whipwreck (2) | Rego Park, NY |
| 01/05/96 | 2 Cold Scorpio (4) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 05/11/96 | Shane Douglas | Philadelphia, PA |
| 06/01/96 | Pitbull #2 | Philadelphia, PA |
| 06/22/96 | Chris Jericho | Philadelphia, PA |
| 07/13/96 | Shane Douglas (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 06/07/97 | Taz (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 03/01/98 | Bam Bam Bigelow | Asbury Park, NJ |
| 04/04/98 | Rob Van Dam | Buffalo, NY |
| 03/12/00 | Super Crazy | Danbury, CT |
| 04/08/00 | Yoshihiro Tajiri | Buffalo, NY |
| 04/22/00 | Rhino | Philadelphia, PA |
| 08/26/00 | Kid Kash | Manhattan, NY |
| 09/09/00 | Rhino (2) | Mississauga, ON |