| Date | Champion | Location |
| 04/25/92 | Jimmy Snuka | Philadelphia, PA |
| 04/26/92 | Johnny Hot Body | Philadelphia, PA |
| 07/12/92 | Jimmy Snuka (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 10/24/92 | Don Muraco | Philadelphia, PA |
| 11/16/92 | The Sandman | Philadelphia, PA |
| 04/03/93 | Don Muraco (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 08/08/93 | Tito Santana | Philadelphia, PA |
| 09/09/93 | Shane Douglas | Roanoke, VA |
| 10/02/93 | Sabu | Philadelphia, PA |
| 12/26/93 | Terry Funk | Philadelphia, PA |
| 03/26/94 | Shane Douglas (2) | Devon, PA |
| 03/15/95 | Sandman (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 10/28/95 | Mikey Whipwreck | Philadelphia, PA |
| 12/09/95 | Sandman (3) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 01/27/96 | Raven | Philadelphia, PA |
| 10/05/96 | Sandman (4) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 12/07/96 | Raven (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 04/13/97 | Terry Funk (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 08/09/97 | Sabu (2) | Philadelphia, PA |
| 08/17/97 | Shane Douglas (3) | Fort Lauterdale, FL |
| 10/16/97 | Bam Bam Bigelow | Queens, NY |
| 11/30/97 | Shane Douglas (4) | Monaco, PA |
| 01/10/99 | Taz | Kissimmee, FL |
| 09/19/99 | Mike Awesome | Villa Park, IL |
| 12/17/99 | Masato Tanaka | Nashville, TN |
| 12/23/99 | Mike Awesome (2) | White Plains, NY |
| 04/13/00 | Tazz (2) | Indianapolis, IN |
| 04/22/00 | Tommy Dreamer | Philadelphia, PA |
| 04/22/00 | Justin Credible | Philadelphia, PA |
| 10/01/00 | Jerry Lynn | St. Paul, MN |
| 11/05/00 | Steve Corino | Villa Park, IL |
| 01/07/01 | The Sandman (5) | Queens, NY |
| 01/07/01 | Rhino | Queens, NY |